Why I’m Giving Up on Foursquare

Posted by: in Communication Strategy, location-based marketing, Social Media Insights & Trends on July 13, 2012

This week, after a year of check-ins, badges and mayorships, I’m walking away from Foursquare. I’m not abandoning the network out of anger, and I won’t even be removing the app or closing my account. I’m just going to stop the endless checking in. I held out on foursquare for longer than I probably should have, as a communications professional, but my colleague Aaron Strout convinced me to give it a whirl.

Aaron is the guy who (literally) wrote the book on location-based marketing, and you can see the initial discussion we had after I took the plunge here.

My year of use has not been without lessons. Here are the five most important:

Via Flickr user dpstyles

  1. “Gamification” is hugely powerful, and foursquare is hugely good at it. While there have been a lot of people trying to capture foursquare’s gaming mojo, it’s hard to replicate the levels of rewards that they built it. Because Facebook wasn’t just about playing a social game against your friends. There was a society-level game you played against strangers (mayorships) and — for the quieter among us — the individual quest for badges, which didn’t require any social element at all.
  2. As a city guide, foursquare is awfully impressive. Because it’s built for mobile, and because the base of engaged users is substantial, the app is a great way to find cool eats and sights in a new place. Of course, you don’t need to be an active foursquare user to treat the app like a guidebook. In this case, it’s the active users that are doing the hard work for the rest of us.
  3. Privacy remains an issue. Griping about privacy is generally a losing proposition for a blogger. What seems to be a massive violation today is likely to be standard practice tomorrow (does anyone remember the months-long carping about how Gmail ads were  going to destroy society? I didn’t think so). But foursquare still gives more information than I’d like, even to people I trust. It’s not because the service in any way evil. It’s just that telling lots of people precisely when you get coffee is baked into the whole idea of the check-in.
  4. Businesses are crippling adoption. If your run a local consumer business, doing a foursquare promotion should be a no-brainer. There are a thousand ways to design specials to dial in a specific commitment/reward level. Yet the number of businesses who are taking advantage of that is minimal. In my year on foursquare, I used exactly one special: on my first day on the service, I received luggage tags for checking into a small, regional airport. That’s not a huge return on the data I’ve invested in the service. I would argue that foursquare’s user base would be larger and more engaged even with a modest increase in the number of promotions. Instead, Foursquare specials remain a wasteland, with notable exceptions. (It doesn’t have to be this way. Have I mentioned Aaron and Location-Based Marketing for Dummies?)
  5. The promise remains unfulfilled. I gave foursquare a ton of my data, and it gives very little back: some recommended places to explore, some badges, and that’s about it. But there is a tremendous amount that could be done. Imagine if Foursquare could take all of my checkins from a week of vacation and plot them on a map, along with the associated status updates and photos. What if I could publish that map to a blog? What if I could order that map as a poster-size souvenir? In short, I’d like to get something more out of my checkins than gamification.

All this doesn’t mean I won’t completely walk away. foursquare is a nice database of the cool places I’ve been (so I can look up that place in North Carolina with the can’t-miss hushpuppies). I’ll use it, quietly and privately, as a note-taking system. And as I mentioned in #2, seeing the comments and check-ins of others is hugely useful and requires no sharing of my own data. But I won’t be mindlessly checking in at the grocery store any more. I’ll still use my grocery rewards card, though. Because — unlike foursquare — I know what I’m getting back each time that bar code gets read.

By: Brian Reid

Brian Reid is a managing director at W2O Group, where he oversees influencer relations. He is a former journalist who believes content really is king.

Find me on: Twitter
Pre-Commerce Check out W2O Group President Bob Pearson's new book, Pre-Commerce, in which he shares ideas for leaders to engage directly with customers to shape their brand and marketplace success. Now available for order on Amazon.com! http://amzn.to/bAmvFN. Join the conversation #precommerce.

One Response

Stay in touch with the conversation, subscribe to the RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. Anonymous said

    Brian, to your fifth point, check out tripline.net. Here’s a map of a trip I took to Anaheim:

    http://tripline.net/trip/Anaheim-2036775165771004B5428F3EBA534026

    There are a lot of cool things that can be done with your foursquare data using the API. Foursquare just doesn’t have time to build them all.

Some HTML is OK

(required)

(required, but never shared)

or, reply to this post via trackback.