Why I Pre-Ordered Coin: Five Reasons For Its Success So Far

Posted by: in Advertising, Analytics, Customer Experience, Insights, Social Commerce, Social Media Insights & Trends, twist on January 28, 2014

By Josh Sowalsky

Coin is a small startup that’s made some pretty big waves on the Internet recently.  Put simply: Coin is a digital and swipeable credit card that holds up to 8 of your credit, debit, reward, and membership cards. Effectively, it will:

Turn this problem:                                                                                      Into this solution:


Take a look at this video to understand the concept:

This nifty little device is only available to pre-order and won’t even be shipped until this summer. So why the heck did I just shell out $50 bucks for some untested technology with zero customer reviews?  5 key strategic components went right for this company, and the data helps tell the story.

#1: The Concept and Design

For me at least, Coin is a good idea. It solves a problem at a fair price. This is the entrepreneurial sweet-spot, and where Google Wallet misses the mark, Coin hits the bullseye – at least until something better comes along. For $50 I can finally fit my essentials into that nice wallet my brother gave me four years ago. But if a great idea that solves a problem were enough to succeed, we’d all be grocery shopping at Webvan. The idea isn’t enough; the idea has to be communicated through the right channels and to the right people.

#2: Getting the Launch (mostly) Right

Coin officially launched on November 14th. Funded by Y Combinator and K9 Ventures, the company’s fundraising goal was 1,000 pre-orders, which they hit in 40 minutes. They would then go on to be “mentioned” almost 14,000 times on Twitter that day alone. And between then and December 31st, the company’s website was visited by nearly half a million unique site visitors. That’s not just dumb luck. This is a well-crafted outreach strategy, which started by getting the right coverage with the right media outlets, using the right content.  

The top shared media outlets that mentioned Coin on Twitter that day were not the large, traditional media outlets. Instead, sites like The Verge, Inc.com, Entrpepreneur.com, Tech Crunch, Venture Beat, CNet, and Gizmodo – all distinctly geeky outlets with early-adopter audiences – ran with the story. By day’s end, over 119 other unique sites had been shared on Twitter featuring original and syndicated stories about Coin. The New York Times eventually got around to picking up the story… and by the time I learned of Coin (much later on), it had a well-established online presence with high hopes and high praise.

By building a large & dedicated community, while co-opting hobbyists & targeting influencers long before its product release date, Coin has turned the technology adoption cycle (AKA “Early Adopter Curve”) upside-down (not literally, of course). This new model blurs the traditional line that has separated the daring “innovator” from the cautious “early adopter.”  Traditionally speaking, the former buys an untested and unproven product, after which the latter follows suit. Yet we may be witnessing a new model, in which after early co-opting of “innovators” proves successful, “early adopters” take on a role once played by the “innovators.” It’s a whole new era.

#3: Brand Personality

New brands today – especially those in tech – have an opportunity to go beyond straight-edge professionalism to present themselves with enthusiasm, charisma, and humor. Brands like Zappos, J Peterman, Philosophers Guild, Trader Joe’s, Vitamin Water and Seamless have done this impeccably for years. These brands are serious about their goals, yet don’t take their personalities too seriously.

Take a minute and read through Coin’s FAQ. I bet chances are good that it makes you smile. To me, the right balance of humor and passion are healthy for a new brand – especially one in technology. Coin found that balance.

#4: Community Management

Let’s start with the bad news and then move toward the good.
You may have noticed above that I wrote that Coin got its launch “mostly” right. Broadly speaking, on November 14th the company hit all the right notes, reached all the right tech influencers, and drove a ton of traffic to its site… but its customer service portal was not equipped to handle the mass of inquiries it received. Armed with a limited staff and Sprout Social – a basic social media management tool – Coin’s customer service team did its best to field an onslaught of questions, but simply could not handle all of the noise. Beyond that, many of the early questions received during the initial onslaught never received responses. That is a serious oversight for a customer service team – no matter how small it is.

Fortunately, Coin’s community management is now back on track. It is generally active and highly responsive. For a cautious “early adopter” on the fence about a purchase, online presence and reliability is critical. Seeing that presence was, in no small part, a factor in my purchasing decision. By the time I was looking into it last week, their customer service process seemed well organized. That’s something that stood out to me and made it easier to have some trust in this company I knew nothing about. Kudos to the Coin team for that!

#5: Sustaining the Buzz

Making high- quality, shareable content today is essential, and Coin’s success so far has been propelled by its highly shareable media. In fact, 37% of Coin’s direct site traffic can be attributed to Facebook and YouTube alone. This is no small feat. In producing solid content and maintaining a highquality digital presence, Coin is helping its cause.

How about some data? As of yesterday (1/27/14), at least $665,000 worth of purchases can be tracked according to unique Twitter share referral links alone. In its slick promotional YouTube video, its sleek website, its comprehensive Q&A, and its seamless referral program, Coin has designed a disruptive product and has launched it in disruptive style.

As far as the data looks, Coin is off to one heck of a start. It will be fascinating to watch where it goes from here. It no doubt will have to overcome emerging privacy and security concerns nationwide, as well as likely push back from the financial sector. The brand has successfully made it through its launch, but how it fares in the future is still to be seen.

I’ll be watching with interest.


(Data in this post is sourced from Sysomos.)

By: Josh Sowalsky

Josh is an Analytics Associate at Twist MKTG. He sometimes has a little too much fun with data. That's pretty much it.

Find me on: Twitter
Pre-Commerce Check out W2O Group President Bob Pearson's new book, Pre-Commerce, in which he shares ideas for leaders to engage directly with customers to shape their brand and marketplace success. Now available for order on Amazon.com! http://amzn.to/bAmvFN. Join the conversation #precommerce.

5 Responses

Stay in touch with the conversation, subscribe to the RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. Brian Reid said

    Love the analysis. It seems, based on my n-of-1 observation of my own Facebook feed, that these guys have also spent a nice chunk of money on paid media to support their social efforts. Curious what kind of an impact that has had …

  2. Josh said

    Thanks Brian (and thank you Lionel)! You can change that to an n-of-2… I’ve definitely noticed their banner ads as well. It’s hard to say how much that has contributed to their success. I used compete data to measure page views, which were sizable enough to assume that the adbuy worked pretty well. And it’s tough to know – for sure – how much a company like coin is spending on adwords. I tend to use Spufu to estimate it, and they’re suggesting that coin is spending $200-$400 per day. Still aint bad. (http://www.spyfu.com/Domain/9053784460901492681)

  3. Agree… very cool analysis Josh. Coin does look like a good idea. Now that Brian mentioned it, there’s another startup who also did well on Facebook, called thingCharger. I missed the deadline to contribute, but it’s a pretty cool product.

  4. Josh said

    Just watched the demo video. That is really cool. I still am crossing my fingers that wireless charging will take off soon… but this definitely a solid solution in the meantime – sort of like Coin actually… A very cool invention that is really just a temporary solution until we’re using our fingerprints or retinas.

  5. Agree on wireless charging. I use the Qi wireless charging for my Nexus 7 most of the time…

Some HTML is OK


(required, but never shared)

or, reply to this post via trackback.